web analytics
Thursday , February 27 2020
Home / NEWS / Africa / LAND IS THE LAST COLONIAL QUESTION IN AFRICA, PROF PLO LUMUMBA ASKS UGANDA TO SORT IT.

LAND IS THE LAST COLONIAL QUESTION IN AFRICA, PROF PLO LUMUMBA ASKS UGANDA TO SORT IT.

 TACKLING UGANDA’S BIGGEST FAULT LINE-LAND, KENYAN LAWYER ADVISES UGANDA’S JUDICIARY ON LAND REFORM.

UGANDA’S LAND REFORMS TAKES SHAPE AS LAND PROBE COMMISSION COMES TO END, KENYA’S PROFFESSOR PATRICK LUMUMBA SAYS JUSTICE CATHERINE BAMUGEMEREIRE’S REPORT  SHOULD  HELP PRESIDENT MUSEVENI TO SORT THE LAST COLONIAL QUESTION IN AFRICA-LAND.

Justice Catherine Bamugemereire’s Land Probe Commission has confronted Uganda’s biggest fault line- LAND. East Africa and most of Southern Africa have failed on land reform only to push the Law reform supported by World Bank and European Union.

Africa’s Intellectual Kenyan Born, Patrick Lumumba delivered a presentation in Uganda’s Gateway “City” of Entebbe at an engagement meeting between the Judiciary and The Commission of Inquiry into Land Matters.

Prof Lumumba discussed a presentation titled, “Independence and Accountability of the Judiciary in the delivery of Land Justice in Africa”.

Lumumba said the British and present rulers have used new laws that have not been redistributive or transformative in a positive way. Longstanding grievances and injustices have not been addressed. Legislation has failed to curtail predatory bureaucracies which in turn have stymied reform through delaying tactics and sabotage.

He said after adopting the 1995 Constitution, Uganda missed a real opportunity to enshrine in law their radical principles for land reform. Even with the Land Act of 1998 that was supposed to operationalize these provisions of the constitution, still the problem of land failed to be resolved.

“It’s the reason President Yoweri Museveni appointed Justice Catherine Bamugemereire and the 6 Commissioners to lead the Commission of Inquiry into land matters”.Justice Catherine Bamugemereire is set to hand over the report to Prresident Museveni for action.

 Proffessor Lumumba says the sensitivity of land matters is nolonger tenable for a judge to listen to a case without going into the finer details.

“Throughout the continent of Africa land remains an emotive issue. The Experiences of 

Zimbabwe, Namibia, South Africa, Kenya, to mention only a few. Kenya’s H.W.O 

Okoth Ogendo was right when he said that land is the last colonial question. 

It is in escapable therefore that disputes will continue to attend land and that the 

Judiciary in every country will continue to play a critical role in dispute resolution. 

The truth however is that while broad principles may be borrowed the peculiarities 

of each jurisdiction will determine how issues are adjudicated. Each country is 

Enjoined to determine issues as informed by history and peculiar circumstances as 

long as justice is watchword”.

According to Lumumba quoted in South Africa, “former President Nelson Mandela would have questioned why a mineral rich continent such as Africa would have remained poor.

“He would have asked how is it that our continent that is so endowed produces what it does not consume and consumes what it does not produce. He would have asked whether the continent of Africa is really liberated. Nelson Mandela would have reminded us that we Africans have suffered more‚” Lumumba said.

The lack of legal title depresses demand for land because potential buyers do not want to negotiate the complexities of proving ownership. No one wants the nightmare of procuring a piece of land that is then mired in contention that prevents business activity from moving forward. Further, the lack of legal ownership also makes it difficult for land holders to come together and combine smaller pieces of land into a mass that can more effectively attract capital investment. In short, both supply and demand are affected by the land question.

Finally, infrastructure development is more costly, mired in delays and incredibly complex because of land issues. In some cases communities do not agree with the valuation of land engendering renegotiations, in other cases absentee landlords make the process of land acquisition long and arduous. However, the most complex is where communities live on what they consider their ancestral land but the land is legally owned by another person or entity.

LESSONS FOR UGANDA 

A survey of diverse experiences in African Jurisdictions offers a number of 

lessons which the Ugandan Judiciary can creatively borrow from and implement 

with due regard to the specificities and peculiarities of Ugandan laws and 

Environment. 

The Kenyan Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Illegal/Irregular 

Allocation of Public Land (Ndungu Report) established to address generally the 

allocation of lands, and in particular: 

To inquire into the allocation, to private individuals or corporations, of 

public lands or lands dedicated or reserved for a public purpose; 

(ii) To collect and collate all evidence and information available, whether 

from ministry-based committees or from any other source, relating to 

the nature and extent of unlawful or irregular allocations of such lands; 

and 

(iii)To prepare a list of all lands unlawfully or irregularly allocated, 

specifying particulars of the lands and of the persons to whom they 

were allocated, the date of allocation, particulars of all subsequent 

dealings in the lands concerned and their current ownership and 

development status; 

(iv) To inquire into and ascertain- (i) the identity of any persons, whether 

individuals or bodies corporate, to whom any such lands were 

allocated by unlawful or irregular means; and (ii) the identity of any 

public officials involved in such allocations; 

(v) To carry out such other investigations into any matters incidental to the 

foregoing as, in the opinion of the commissioners, will be beneficial to 

a better and fuller discharge of their commission; 

(vi) To carry out such other investigations as may be directed by the 

President or the Minister for Lands and Settlement 

(vii) to recommend- legal and administrative measures for the 

restoration of such lands to their proper title or purpose, having due 

regard to the rights of any private person having any bona fide 

entitlement to or claim of right over the lands concerned; 

(viii) legal and administrative measures to be taken in the event that 

such lands are for any reason unable to be restored to their proper title 

or purpose; 

(ix) Criminal investigation or prosecution of, and any other measures to be 

taken against, persons involved in the unlawful or irregular allocation 

of such lands; and 

(x) Legal and administrative measures for the prevention of unlawful or 

irregular allocations of such land in the future. 

The Ndungu Report offers lessons which Uganda can borrow from. Some of the 

Lessons include: 

1. Establishment of a Land Titles Tribunal

a. Each case of a suspected illegal or irregular allocation of public land 

must be dealt with on its own merits. 

2. Computerization of Land Records

a. One of the main problems which has fueled the illegal allocation of 

public land is the poor and chaotic record keeping system in the 

Ministry of Lands and Settlement and in the District Registries. Because 

of poor records, members of the public are unable to trace and keep 

track of the history transactions relating to particular titles of land. 

Quite often, records have been falsified or even hidden so as to 

conceal illegal allocations of land. 

3. Insurance of Land Titles Members of the public 

Page 26 of 29 

a. Members of the public should be able to rely on a Title Deed 

document in which to transact either as buyers or sellers of land. 

b. If land is to be freely transferable on the market then a secure system 

of titling must be devised. 

c. It is therefore recommended that a comprehensive land Title Insurance 

Scheme be established in the country 

d. A consortium of Insurance companies should be encouraged and 

licensed to offer insurance services in this regard. This will eliminate 

risk and uncertainty of dealing with forged titles. 

4. Establishment of a Land Commission 

The absence a centralized and professional body charged with the 

duty of land administration has facilitated the illegal allocation of land. 

5. Enhancing the Capacity of Institutions: 

a. The technical and personnel capacities in the Ministry of Lands and 

Settlement, the Judiciary and the Attorney General’s Chambers should 

be enhanced so as to competently and efficiently deal with land 

matters. All ministries and local authorities dealing with the 

administration of public land should have properly trained legal 

personnel to advise them and to ensure reliable representation in 

courts of law. 

b. The Government is also obliged to protect the public interest by 

enforcing the development conditions strictly and by refusing to 

consent to any dealing with the land until such conditions have been 

complied with. 

c. Allocations of developed public land e.g. Government houses, should 

generally be made at market value. 

6. Inventory of All Public Land: 

a. There appears to be no complete record or register of public land in 

the country. Some Ministries, State Corporations and Departments 

cannot give a comprehensive account of what public land they hold. 

b. It is therefore recommended that all Ministries, Local Authorities, and 

State Corporations should maintain registers of all assets they hold. 

These registers should be updated annually. 

Page 27 of 29 

c. The Government should prepare an inventory of all public land in the 

country. 

7. Harmonization of Land Legislation 

The Government should harmonize land legislation to prevent double 

issuance of land titles and other abuses. 

8. Restitution 

The Government should embark upon the legal recovery of all monies 

that were unjustly gotten through the illegal allocation and sale of 

Public Land. The recovery should be extended to original allotees, 

professionals, brokers,etc. 

9. Prosecution 

All public officials, private individuals, companies and professionals 

who participated in the illegal allocation of public land in ways that 

disclose the commission of crimes should be investigated, prosecuted 

and/or retired from public service in the public interest 

10. Upgrading Informal Settlements 

Illegal allocations of public land have greatly contributed to the spread 

of informal settlements in the main urban centres in the country. The 

Government should initiate programmes to address the problem of 

such  settlements. 

About Goodluck Musinguzi

Check Also

ABSA BANK UGANDA LICENSED BY BANK OF UGANDA

ABSA GROUP AFRICA’S BEST DEVELOPING INVESTMENT BANK GETS LICENCE AS ABSA BANK UGANDA Welcome to …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *